Direct Mail for Insurance Agents

We help make your

phone ring

with interested homeowners

Direct Mail Marketing Helps You:

As an insurance agent

You know the importance of sharing how families have trusted A-rated insurance providers to protect their assets for generations. But, how can you reach them above the noise of social media and online advertising?

That’s where direct mail marketing comes in.

At Next Level Marketing, we specialize in direct mail marketing for insurance agents. We’ve helped hundreds of agents just like you bind hundreds of thousands of dollars in policies and create loyal customers who stay with their insurance agent for generations.

We believe every agent has a unique story to tell.

Being an insurance agent means serving residents, connecting with your neighbors, and supporting great causes within your community. Targeting your ideal customer allows you to share your story and invite them to be a part of building their community with you.

Why Agents Choose Us

Increase HO-3 book of business
Build brand awareness and trust
Increase productivity
Only talk to interested prospects
Grow your PIF count
Reach carrier bonuses
Fiduciary goal achievement

Exclusive

We protect our agents' interest by providing them exclusive rights to their zip codes. In doing so our agents enjoy higher contact rates than our competitors and in turn generate more sales.

Competitive Pricing

The more you send, the more you save and unlike our competitors we don't charge you extra for our innovation. Minimum 2,500 mail pieces per month.

Innovative

Prospects scan a QR code or access the site with their personalized URL. That page has a photo of their home to grab their attention. They can amend the mailed coverage, add their auto for a bundled proposal and submit it to your office for a quote.

Scan the QR Code

Scan the sample QR code or click here to view a sample prospect landing page!

Testimonials

"I have been using Next Level Marketing for my mailers for over 10 years and it has been a very important part of our marketing process. We have other marketing that we do, but this is the best and most consistent. There are others out there that are similar, but the total turnkey operation works well for us and that why we will continue to use them.

If you’re not using them as a part of your marketing... you’re missing out!!!"

"I’ve done a few different mail programs in the past and these are by far the best. I have been using these mailers for over a year and this program is 100x more successful than any marketing program I have used in the past and actually generates more traction than buying internet leads. They are professional looking and have a QR code as well as a link that the prospect can go to and request a quote.

I’ve been using these mailers as the only marketing for my protégé producer. Through 8 ½ months in the program, she has generated 208,322 in P/C premium for an average of $23,146/month. These numbers are a direct result of the mailers. Our phones ring off the hook the first half of the month with calls for quotes from the mailer. I’ve recommended them to fellow agents and even district managers for new agents and protégé producers and they have enjoyed similar success.

NLM is great to work with and always there if I have any questions, concerns or special requests. These mailers are a winner for your agency and your ROI."

"I have been using Next Level Marketing for my mailers for over 10 years and have built my agency almost exclusively on these inbound calls. We do other marketing, but nothing is as effective as when the customers call you ready to buy."

"Next level Marketing is the real deal, I have been a customer for 15 years and will be for another 15 years."

“I’ve built my agency through direct mail and no matter what market I’ve been in my agency has continued to grow. In 2021 I wrote a little over 1.9 million in personal lines premium exclusively with direct mail”

our process

We create a marketing radius for your agency with filters designed for your area
We provide the highest quality lead source
We build a custom rating model for your agency
We print and mail the leads
You answer the phone and close the sale

Get In Touch

Our team of experts will work with you to create a customized direct mail campaign that speaks to your clients and showcases the value of your agency. We’ll help you clarify your unique value proposition and create a marketing plan that drives results.

Don’t let the overwhelm of marketing hold you back any longer.

Take the first step towards growing your agency and contact us today to get started.

Please fill out the form below

frequently asked questions

Why should I use direct mail?

Smart insurance agents build their business on relationships. Direct mail allows you to start the relationship with a personalized, targeted message.

In a digital world, people crave a human connection. Direct mail can help you stand out from the noise and connect right from the beginning.

How can you track success with direct mail?

Our Professional clients have access to reporting data to view the inbound phone call metrics generated from your direct mailouts.

What makes NLM different from the other mail companies?

NLM offers the simplest, most comprehensive turn-key solution for direct mail.

We will scrub your list, provide personal URLs & QR codes, print, pack, and send. We also provide phone call tracking and reporting.

We offer our clients exclusivity for certain zip codes, so you will never be competing with other NLM clients. And we will provide an exclusive proven home pre-quote mailer that you can use in your target market.